Friday, May 25, 2012

D&D Next Playtest: How to Play

If you read yesterday's post, you already know the fiasco that became WotC's distribution of the D&D Next playtest materials.  I will not go over it again.  I got my playtest mats close to midnight. Today, I will tell you a little bit about the new rules being tested.  The new rules are short and sweet, and take me back to the late 70s and early 80s, when I was playing OD&D and then AD&D.

THINGS THAT HAVE NOT CHANGED

You still have the traditional six abilities (strength, dexterity, constitution, intelligence, wisdom and charisma) and their modifiers.  I don't think anyone was expecting any changes here.

Checks and Difficulty Class ("DC")  are still there.  Some of them are referred to as 'contests', like when you try to force open a door that a troll is holding shut from the other side.  The player and the troll each make a check and the highest one wins.

Attacks are very much the same.  Roll 1d20, add bonuses and penalties, compare to target's Armor Class ("AC").

Time hasn't changed.  Combat rounds still represent about six seconds each.

Natural 1 is an automatic miss, natural 20 is a critical hit, and critical hits deal the maximum possible damage for the attack.

There are different damage types: slashing, piercing, fire, etc.  Like in 4E, in most occasions the damage type is not important, except when the target of the attack has a vulnerability or resistance to it.

The option of dealing nonlethal damage is still there for melee attacks.

Arcane and divine magic are still here.  There are unconfirmed rumors of "a strange form of power that derives from the mind".


THINGS THAT ARE GONE

Attacks of opportunity ("AoO")  are now gone.  I guess AoO will become one of those "modular" things you and your group can choose to incorporate, or not, into your campaign.  There is also talk of optional abilities you can train that would grant you an AoO, but only once per round instead of against every creature that provoked on AoO in that round.   I have to see this in action before I am fully convinced by it.  However, I am inclined to like it as absence of AoO's should speed up combat a bit.

Fortitude, Reflex and Will are gone. That's because your attacks are against AC.

Concealment is gone, or maybe absorbed by cover.  See below.

Second wind is gone. So are healing surges.

Weapon proficiency bonuses are gone. 


THINGS THAT HAVE CHANGED

I initially thought about naming this section "Things That Are New", but then realized that the title would be misleading.  Point of fact: spell casting.  In D&D Next, most of your spell attacks are against AC.  This is new in comparison to 4E, but it is not new in D&D as this is how OD&D and AD&D used to work.  Thus, things that have "changed" seems more appropriate than things that are "new".

Saving throws and DCs are a little less arbitrary now.  Let's say your wizard casts a burning hands spell in a cone in front of him.  In 4E, this would be an Int vs Reflex attack, with the creatures taking half damage if you missed your roll.  Now, burning hands hits all the creatures in the cone.  However, each creature gets to roll a saving throw.  While the DC for the saving throw is not static, the formula is: 10 + your relevant magic ability modifier (usually Int or Wis).  This is reminiscent of 3 and 3.5, and is one of the things I liked about those versions.

Movement has been simplified. Take jump, for example.  In 4E,you had to roll an Athletics check, divide by ten, consult a table... Now, a long jump with a 10 feet running start is a maximum of your Str score.  Without the running start, half that distance.  A high jump with a 10 feet running start is 3 + your Str modifier.  Without the running start, just your Str modifier (minimum 1). I appreciate not having to fire up my Excel spreadsheet to calculate how far or how high a player can jump.  Climb, Swim, Crawl and Stand Up have been similarly simplified.

I love the way Prone has been modified.  Before, you had to spend your entire move action just to stand up. Now, standing up from a Prone position uses only 5 feet of your total movement. This means you can stand up from a Prone position and move around the battlefield.

Surprise has changed quite a bit.  A creature who is surprised takes a -20 penalty to its initiative.

Concealment is gone, substituted by the all-encompassing Cover.  A creature can enjoy Half Cover (+2 to AC), Three-Quarters Cover (+5 to AC) and Full Cover (cannot be targeted for attacks).  Contrary to 4E, if an ally is between you and a creature, that ally grants the creature Half Cover, or +2 bonus to the creature's AC...  and if your ally is fat enough, he could grant the creature Three-Quarters Cover, lol!  Ah, well, that's how I would rule it, anyway...  but then again, that's why I am Bad DM.

Casting a spell or making a ranged attack while in melee range used to provoke an AoO.  Now, it places you in a disadvantage. Check the "Things That Are New" section below to learn about this new bonus/penalty mechanism.

Resistance and vulnerability are different now.  Before, a creature could have a resistant fire 5, and 5 points would be subtracted from the damage roll.  Now, resistance halves all damage of that type, while vulnerability doubles it.

Death has changed a bit.  In 4E, you die if your hit points drop below your negative bloodied value.  Now, you die when your hit points drop to a negative value equal to your Con score plus your character's level.  A 3rd level fighter with a Con of 17 dies if his hit points drop to 20.

Dying can sometimes be deadlier than in 4E, depending how far below 0 hit points the attack left you, but in most instances should prove less so.  In 4E, you roll 1d20 on each round that you are unconscious (at or below 0 hit points).  If you roll below 10 three times before taking a rest or receiving any healing, you die.  In theory, you could spend a 15-round fight unconscious as long as you never rolled below 10 more than twice.  Now, you roll a DC 10 Con saving throw. On a success, you remain dying but your condition does not worsen.  Three successes and you become stabilized. However, every failure inflicts 1d6 damage on your character.  This damage cannot be reduced in any way.  Depending on how close you are to your death value (Con + lvl), one failure may be all you need to visit the underworld.

Healing has an interesting mechanic.  You can heal yourself during a short rest but you must have a healer's kit.  The healer's kit allows you to spend one or more of your hit dice, up to your maximum hit dice, for healing.  For each hit die you spend, roll the die and add your Con modifier.  The result is the amount of hit points you gain.  Once you have used up all your hit dice, you must spend a long rest to regain them.  For example, the 1st level dwarf fighter pregen included with the playtest mats has a hit dice of 1d12 and, with a Con score of 14, a Con modifier of +2.  During a short rest and if he had a healer's kit, this dwarf fighter would roll 1d12, add +2 to the die roll, and that would be the amount of hit points he would gain.  At 1st level, he only has 1 hit die, so the healer's kit will not avail him again until he takes a long rest and regains his hit die.  Taking a long rest replenishes both your hit dice and your lost hit points, but you can only take one long rest every 24 hours.  A healer's kit has ten uses.

Conditions have pretty much stayed the same, except that those that would impose a penalty/benefit to an attack roll, AC, etc., now grant Advantage/Disadvantage instead.

Vancian magic is back.  Wizards and clerics, the two magic-using classes for the playtest, have a combination of minor spells (cantrips for wizards and orisons for clerics) that can be used as often and whenever they want, and high level spells.  Contrary to cantrips and orisons, higher level spells must be prepared beforehand and assigned a slot of the spell's level or higher.


THINGS THAT ARE NEW

The playtest rules have something I don't recall seeing in earlier editions.  They call it Advantage/Disadvantage.  Basically, when situations give you an edge, like when you attack from a hidden position, you get an advantage.  You can get an advantage to attacks, checks or saving throws.  Having an advantage means that you get to roll a second d20.  You then get to use the highest roll for your result.  In the case of a disadvantage, you must use the lowest roll.

Thursday, May 24, 2012

The D&D Next Playtest Has Begun!

That was the subject of an email I received from Wizards Customer Support at 9:29 a.m.  After clicking on the provided link, I was taken to a login screen to confirm my D&D Insider account.  D&D Insider members get to start the playtest a little bit sooner than non-members.  After loging in and executing the pertinent agreements, you then have to wait 30-60 minutes for another email with the actual download link for the D&D Next playtest materials.

There is one thing I did like about the new D&D Next Playtest Agreement.  The non-disclosure part of it has been seriously relaxed.  You still cannot distribute, display, disseminate, blah, blah, blah...  the actual playtest materials.  However, now you can publicly discuss your thoughts about the materials and your experience with them.  This is great!

As you know, every Sunday my 4E group gets together to play a modified version of the War of the Burning Sky set in the Forgotten Realms.  This Sunday, however, we'll be running the D&D Next playtest materials.  As a result of the revised D&D Next Playtest Agreement, we'll be able to post our comments and opinions on this first round of the playtest.


Update (11:41 p.m.): download link working.  Got my playtest material.

 Update (8:50 p.m.): no solutions from Wizards yet, other than try again later and hope there are less people occupying the servers.  Support thread closed again.  Its been over 10 hours and still can't get my playtest materials from WotC.  That's it for me for tonight.  Am going to some more of The Wind Through the Keyhole.

Update (6:49 p.m.): still no relief in sight for the droves of playtesters who cannot get their playtest materials due to the inadequacy of WotC's IT department. I must admit that this particular post made me laugh like a madman about the whole situation:

Well, after 8 hours of playtesting, I'm disappointed with 5E. The documents are incredibly sparse. It only seems to have one monster called "HTTP Error", and I can't figure out whether 400 is its AC, or its hit points, or what. And there aren't any character pregens, so I can't even see how an encounter might go.

Update (5:15 p.m.): support thread reopened, severs still unavailable for most playtesters, including us.


Update (4:55 p.m.): after 47 pages, Wizards closed the D&D Next Playtest support thread.  Sigh...

Update (4:13 p.m.): Wizards' playtest rollout has been a major FUBAR. The thread where Wizards' inability to provide adequate server/bandwith for the downloads is being discussed has hit over 50,000 views. The few playtesters that have been able to get their materials are attempting to help the majority by placing the playtest materials on other file sharing services like rapidshare, etc.  Of course, this is in violation of the Playtest Agreement. So, right now, we have a race in the Wizards' Community forums, with playtesters posting links to alternate download services and forum moderators erasing those posts almost as soon as they're up. So ridiculous...  6 hours later I still cannot download my playtest materials from the Wizards' servers...

Update (2:59 p.m.): Wizards' servers still cannot put up with the demand. One D&D Insider member put it best a few minutes ago, when he wrote in the Wizards Community forums:

Tried the multitude of links the have been presented between here and Enworld...Sure enough, no luck. Thanks WOTC. This is why Paizo is wrecking you. I guess i'll try back tomorrow.

Update (1:50 p.m.):  After several hours trying and retrying the download links, a good number of people have been unable to get their playtest materials - myself included. It appears that Wizards' servers cannot handle the amount of traffic the public playtest has generated.  This is baffling to me. Considering this wave of playtesting is limited to D&D Insider subscribers, how could Wizards not have foreseen the number of people that would be hitting their servers for their playtest materials? Of course, the online community is nerd-raging in the Wizards community forums, and I think I agree with them. This should not have happened.

Monday, May 21, 2012

Escaping Bloodstone Pass, Part I

Editor's Note: what follows is the latest update of the Rage Against Vaasa campaign, a version of War of the Burning Sky set in the Forgotten Realms. For more information, check out our Rage Against Vaasa page.

It is the third day after the attack and the skies in the afternoon are clearer. Unlike the previous night, no snowfall hampers the Vasaan siege. As the party rests, the refugees within learn of the events occurring outside the safe house. At sunset, an Inquisitor delivered a message to the soldiers at the western gate: Allow a group of Inquisitors into the city or the attacks will be renewed. If the party will see its mission through, they must leave Bloodstone Pass now!

After discussing several options for leaving the city, they conclude that their best option is attempting to secure the aid of Councilman Erdan Menash.  The party still has the orders discovered at the warehouse where they fought the White Wyrms terrorist group and that made reference to an attempt on the Councilman's person.  Maybe they can convince the Councilman that his best bet to stay alive is to leave Bloodstone Pass, with the party as his bodyguards.

In the nobles’ district, in the shadow of the 90-foot statue of the now deceased Emperor Coaltongue, a manor painted vivid green, yellow, and purple stands at the edge of the grand square. Three stories tall, its garish appearance is matched only by the equally garish tabards the Councilman’s guards wear. Despite their appearance, the guards are polite and professional and usher the party into the grand salon.

If the building’s outside seemed odd, the interior of the manor is simply bizarre. Exotic weapons from all corners of the world adorn the walls. Whips, strange orc weapons called urgroshes, double axes, double swords, monk weapons, and even a heavy repeating crossbow designed to look like a porcupine; everything — even the now trite spiked chain — is made more exotic by unorthodox decorations like red and yellow frogs on pommels, or axeheads in the shape of bunnies. The only room that is not strange or unusual is the small chapel to the god of knowledge that is to the right of the grand salon. The party is informed that the councilman is not in; he is in a council meeting, but he will return soon. They are invited to wait until he arrives.

When Erdan arrives he is frustrated, complaining in a high-pitched, wheezing voice about the nincompoops in charge of the city. He does a double take when he sees the party, surprised to have guests.  Erdan asks their names and their business, and was especially interested in details of what happened to them during the attack two nights ago. Erdan, however, seems to have a bad case of ADD.  On more than one occasion, he interrupted party members to give them a tour of his house’s many oddities.

After a very frustrating audience, Erdan refused to abandon Bloodstone Pass.  His duty is with his people and his city. However, he understands the importance of the party's mission - once it was divulged to him - and he will aid them in their escape from Bloodstone Pass.  He also bequeaths the party with gear of his own design.  A pink plate mail armor with flamingo beak helmet, green feathers adorning the waist area and purple feather adornments protruding from the shoulders; a short sword with the blade in the shape of a dolphin; a dagger with a banana-shaped hilt and pommel; and other similarly garish gear.

Erdan also gave them a note for Captain Herreman and directions to his post (located one district to the east, less than a mile away, near a large stable and barracks), begged them to send aid as soon as they can, and bid them good luck. Just before the party exits, he excitedly called them back. “Just one more thing!” he said as he motioned the party towards the chapel.

From underneath the small table of worship items, Erdan pulled out a package about the size of a fist and handed it to the party. He explained that this odd item was discovered in the old dwarven galleries under Bloodstone Pass in a recent excavation, and he can find no explanation of what it is, but the Lyceum might know. He asked that the party deliver it to Dougan Rambausen, a dwarf instructor at the academy. He hoped that an answer to its origin could be found.

This strange blue device is a marvel of dwarven technology. Despite its age, it appears new and shiny. A small door appears on the front with a glass window just above it. Four strangely marked buttons are found on the top and a small plate containing Dwarven runes appears to be instructions, but the dialect is not translatable. A number of holes cover the back and the sides have a fine-mesh grill covering a shallow depression. The technical skill that made this object appears lost in today’s society. It is lightweight and warm to the touch. There are no visible screws to allow one to open the box. A translatable formal text does show what appears to be its name, “Dianoem – Mk IV.”